Gisela’s Birmingham Post article // June 18th, 2008 // Speeches, Articles and Interviews
Gisela Stuart MP
Labour MP – Birmingham Edgbaston
The Mad Hatter told Alice that, “words mean what you want them to mean”. He would have felt at home in the EU. The Irish have said “No” to the Lisbon Treaty which all governments agreed could only be ratified by unanimity. That should be the end of it, yet already Europe’s politicians and bureaucrats are looking for a way to plough on.
When the heads of governments meet next week at the European Council, the Irish government is being asked to explain why the people voted the way they did! I doubt a similar explanation would have been required for a “yes”- it would simply have been accepted. Some straight talking is needed: the Treaty is dead and it’s no good trying to bully a country like Ireland.
The referendum result is not a problem for the Irish: it’s a problem for the whole of Europe, because it reflects a deeper malaise. The project of Europe’s political elite - deeper political integration – can no longer rely on implicit consent, let alone a popular mandate. This elite is incapable of comprehending the meaning of the word “no”, simply arguing in a high handed and arrogant way that the people didn’t understand, shouldn’t have been asked in the first place or were voting on something else other than the Treaty.
How did we get into this mess?
It all began quite promisingly: in the 2001 Laeken Declaration leaders of European governments appeared to recognise that the problem for the EU and its institutions was that they were out of touch with the peoples of Europe. So they set up the Convention on the Future of Europe where representatives form all national parliaments, the European Parliament, governments and the Commission came to together in public session to find a solution. I represented the UK Parliament and served on the drafting committee.
The Convention was supposed to examine the allocation of power between the Union and Member States, but instead, the former French president Valerie Giscard D’Estaing, who chaired the proceedings, determined that a constitution was needed.
By the end I for one was completely disillusioned with a project so driven by a small political elite. At the time my views were seen as eccentric, but I recall resisting fiercely the inclusion of a clause which required a country which failed to ratify the constitution within two years to leave the European Union. The assumption was that Britain, rather than as it turned out France, Holland and Ireland, would be problem.
The early confidence that if asked the people would support the project was quickly shattered. Two founder member states said no. The French apparently agreed with my spell check – during the Convention, whenever I typed in the word Giscard, it suggested “discard”!
Rather than accept the people’s verdict, the EU opted for a “period of reflection” but in due course the constitution was served up as a new dish: the Treaty of Lisbon. Giscard D’Estaing summed it up by saying “it’s the same letter, just in a different envelope”. Some changes were made – sufficient for the Government in Britain to renege on the promised referendum – but the Treaty was completely and utterly unreadable.
Misinformation and dissembling followed. First, we were told that there would be no enlargement without the Treaty or the EU would grind to a halt, but new countries have joined and the EU continued working; later it was said that the Lisbon Treaty wasn’t such a big deal after all, much less significant than Maastricht or Nice. So if it’s so “modest” – why the fuss about its rejected? In fact the Lisbon Treaty was an ill disguised attempt to get through the back door what couldn’t be got through the front.
Now the Irish have said “no” and not on low turnout or by a narrow margin. Their reasons may have been varied, but so are the reasons for voting in general elections and opinion polls suggest the underlying theme was clear: what they - and what many more if they had been given chance - rejected was the incomprehensible bureaucratic structure of the EU which makes it impossible to pin down responsibility and accountability for decisions.
The Treaty is dead, so the Labour government should not push ahead with the third reading of the Lisbon Treaty in the House of Lords next week. If it was right for a “period of reflection” after the Dutch and French voted “no”, it is appropriate for the UK to pause after the Irish vote.
The Queen’s Speech is not until 4th of December and Gordon Brown needs to respond strategically rather tactically to the new reality and put his own proposal on the table rather than reacting to others: that’s a game that Whitehall likes playing, but does so badly- the notion that “Britain is winning the argument” is nonsense.
Gordon Brown should appoint a Minister for Europe within the Cabinet, who would be answerable to Parliament on all EU issues. The first priority for the new minister would be to draw up proposals for returning powers to Member States. The basis would be the presumption that the EU would only do those things for which there is an overwhelming argument that it can not be done by the nation states.
My guess is that there is appetite for real change in the way the EU is run among the peoples of Europe; but if governments continue to sideline their voters and choose to consolidate an unelected and unaccountable nomenklatura, national self interests will argue for a different relationship with the EU than the present one.
A new initiative from Britain might well come as a shock, but Europe needs to be shocked into action. It’s not the Irish “no-vote” that’s the problem. The EU is heading for a major economic and financial crisis and discredited political elites and an outdated European model is ill-quipped to deal with it: as Barak Obama might say, “It’s time for a change”.
81 Comments to “Gisela’s Birmingham Post article”
Leave a CommentYour e-mail will not be displayed on this website
- Your Comments
- diamond exchange global said: Nice writing style. I will put your site on my bl...
- the sindbad in hammamet said: err i keep getting an error when trying to skip to...
- hotels in sfax said: Nice writing style. you have a website aswell. By...
- hotels in les berges du lac said: Moin Well said...
- diamond heart pendant necklace said: Hi The download didnt work for me, thanks for teh ...
- dog community said: You would think that they world have OKd it at teh...
- great george orwell play... wigan peer.. on R4 now. Tune in 15 hrs ago
- IDS welfare reforms. We all want people to be better off in work than out. Let's hope he gets it right. 21 hrs ago
- listening to Digby Jones on R4....Labour made him a minister and gave him a peerage... which party does he think he belongs to? 1 day ago
- Bet you Cameron will come to regret having his India visit overshadowed by his incautious comments. 2 days ago
- getting ready for meeting in Department of Health re: Birmingham proposal for physician assistants 3 days ago
- now we know it. when Cameron goes on holiday.... Clegg won't be left in charge. 4 days ago
- good news. Con-Dem government U-turn on naming those charged with rape. 5 days ago
- going to Bromsgrove supporting David Miliband in Labour Party meeting tonight 1 week ago
- Coalition in a bit of a Pickle over tuition fees and graduate tax. LibDems discovering government not as as easy as they thought 1 week ago
- have written to BBC today to ask why there is no director of programmes for the West Midlands as there is for North West 1 week ago
- More updates...
- European Affairs | Business of the House | Commons debates
- European Affairs | Business of the House | Commons debates
- European Affairs | Business of the House | Commons debates
- European Affairs | Business of the House | Commons debates
- European Affairs | Business of the House | Commons debates
- Treatment of Detainees | Oral Answers to Questions - Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Commons debates
- Afghanistan | Oral Answers to Questions - Prime Minister | Commons debates
- NHS White Paper | Oral Answers to Questions - Education | Commons debates
- Points of Order | Commons debates
- Allied Health Professions | Health | Written Answers
Why is this cost increasing when enrollment is decreasing?
Report comment
By teenage sex | July 1, 2010
Lerman, it is a great post thanks for writing it!
Report comment
By teenage sex | July 2, 2010
Продаются Английские удочки:
1) Новый Супер пикер - DRENNAN MATCHPRO QUIVER 10 ft to 11 ft COMBO - цена 15000 р
2) Б/у но в хорошем состоянии фидер - DRENNAN STILWATER FEEDER 12′6 ft - цена 10000 р
3) Б/у но в хорошем состоянии фидер - Drennan 9′6” - 11′ Carp Feeder Combo Puddle Chucker - цена 6500 р
4) Б/у но в хорошем состоянии карповик - FOW WARRIOR ELITE 2.75 lb - 2 шт за 15000 р
5) Б/у но в хорошем состоянии карповик - GREYS X-FLITE 3 lb - 3 шт за 30000 р
6) Б/у но в хорошем состоянии катушки FOX STRATOS 10000 со сменными шпулями и леской на них - 3 шт за 10000
телефон 8-девятьсот десять-436-31-33
email marlinfisher2010СОБАКАgmail.com
Пишите на мыло или звоните
Вышлю в любой регион при предоплате
Report comment
By MoobamnSymn | July 2, 2010
recicologias.com.br - tizanidine info
Report comment
By tizanidine cnb | July 6, 2010
Hi. I’m interested in placing classified ads on this situation web site. I cannot find the contact form so right here I am.
Report comment
By free credit card numbers | July 6, 2010
Open to tackling a range of tasks?
Report comment
By social network AltroVita | July 10, 2010
Good day! We are longing for long run freelancers, may well you be curious? This will never make you rich yet there is an intriguing compensation and if you exceptionally cherish writing then it opportunity is for you.
Report comment
By hannah montana fashion | July 10, 2010
Thank you for this valuable post. It changed my way
Report comment
By Listen to Music Online | July 10, 2010
Hello. And Bye.
Report comment
By XRumerTest | July 11, 2010
mission trip to africa for teens
Report comment
By Horogbabsa | July 11, 2010
Ситуация вот какая. Меня недавно попросили поработать модератором на форуме. И, чёрт возьми, мне это понравилось:)
А вот недавно я увидел ваш форум и прикинул: А почему бы и здесь не попроситься в модеры. Вопрос: можно ли у вас стать модератором, и если да, то как?
Report comment
By Hamital | July 15, 2010
jokolopokolo
Report comment
By Terrabablo | July 15, 2010
Путаны помогут разообразить ваш dosug. Лучшие, дорогие, дешевые, элитные проститутки Питера и Москвы. Услуги московских проституток на нашем сайте. prostitutka svetlana staruhi prostitutkibljadi kemerovo
Report comment
By putanaxxl | July 15, 2010
Hello. And Bye.
Report comment
By EnawayEscab | July 16, 2010
it was very interesting to read.
I want to quote your post in my blog. It can?
And you et an account on Twitter?
Report comment
By meldmanv | July 16, 2010
Bed, depart, restaurant in Turkey and in cities such as Istanbul, Bodrum and Ankar
Report comment
By Slon | July 17, 2010
“Элитное Такси ” - все автомобили лишены опознавательных знаков службы такси!
Почувствуй себя настоящим королём с собственным водителем и гарсоном!
Что у нас в салоне? В салоне у нас полный беспредел!
Wi-Fi зона выхода в интернет
Аккустика Mysteria 5.1 – лучшая в своём классе
чисто
Report comment
By elitetaxx | July 25, 2010
What I wouldnt give to have a argue with you about this. You just say so many things that come from out of nowhere that Im pretty sure I would have a fair shot.
Your blog is great to look at, I mean people wont be bored to tears. But others who can see past the videos and the layout will not be so impressed with your generic insight of this subject.
Report comment
By Health Insurance Quotes | July 25, 2010
Auto Loan, Bad Credit Loans,Bank Loan,Business Loan, Home Loan,Payday Loan
Report comment
By goodloanweb | July 26, 2010
Hey guys,
Report comment
By SBIGGY | July 26, 2010
Need unsecured loan or business lending? Break Loan called also auto loans, commercial loans, home equity loans, payday loans, personal loans, student loans and va loans.
Report comment
By breakloancom | July 26, 2010
продам холодильник на бмв
Report comment
By Bwmfannnatic | July 27, 2010
Online world and international news, british online service.
Report comment
By amongnews | July 27, 2010
Hello! gdaedeg interesting gdaedeg site!
Report comment
By Pharmc459 | July 27, 2010
Very nice site!
Report comment
By Pharma935 | July 27, 2010
Radisson Diamond Cruise Reviews Hundreds of discounts crystal Cruise.
Report comment
By radissoncruiseorg | July 28, 2010
На нашем портале вы найдете вульгаризм об автомобилях газ. Также вашему вниманию предоставлены саме свежие автомобильные новости, новости и финансовые отчеты крупных российских и зарубежных фирм, которые выпускают автомобили, масла, автозапчасти.
Report comment
By haclephesee | July 29, 2010
I just book marked your blog on Digg and StumbleUpon.I enjoy reading your commentaries.
Report comment
By noni juice | July 29, 2010
Hey guys I’m not confident if this is the best forum to put this, but I am having some real grieve learning asian brides I infer from asian brides that blog, but it actually didn’t seem to give alot of substance to me. Can someone please serve me? It’s so impregnable to convene the woman of my dreams.
This ezine wasn’t coherant to read
Ideas on How to satisfy Women for the Local mall
If you may be just one guy and aren’t the optimal at locating a lot less meeting ladies and are wondering the place you might head to uncover and interact with a girlfriend, then these ten reasonable guidelines on how to meet a gal with the shopping mall, must appear in mighty handy.
1 - Go for the foods court. Think it or not, the foodstuff court may be the absolute optimal put inside shopping mall to meet a lady. Here’s what you do. Choose a foods location and get in line for the meal. While you might be in line, check close to the area the place everyone is sitting down and eating. Appearance for a young girl sitting down alone, or even two women sitting together. When you might have your meal in hand, walk more than to exactly where she or they can indeed be sitting and request if you can actually join them. If you are truthful and straightforward with them, your chances are fairly high-quality.
2- Do some considering. Prior to you even contemplate heading to your shopping mall to satisfy a young girl, sit your own self down and do some considerable contemplating. Look at how you could possibly fulfill a lady and what you might say to her if you’re the one successful. Take into account which components with the local mall you’ll check out. Also, you’re likely to should obtain some thing even while there, what do you need? At last, give consideration to what meeting a female in a public put entails. Undoubtedly you’ll need to check to get a wedding ring earlier than speaking with a girlfriend, and you’ll ought to start thinking about if it is wiser to speak into a chick alone or just one who is with others. In conclusion, you are going to have to get practical about your personal age and also the ages associated with the girl you need to meet. As in, you are likely to really need to tell on your own being reasonable and do not look at to meet women that happen to be a lot younger or older than you’re, or that take a look out of one’s league.
3 - Request assistance. As soon as you can be at long last with the local mall, 1 of the approaches to meet women is by asking them for help. Females be aware that males have no plan what they may be performing when they are purchasing, so asking for assistance will not seem such a ridiculous strategy. Request assist in picking out a jacket for on your own for example. Doing so let’s the woman know that you just are single. If she agrees to help you, talk to her other queries as you grab diverse jackets to try out on.
Hey guys I’m not persuaded if this is the greatestl forum to mail this, but I am having some real strife learning asian brides I infer from asian brides that blog, but it really didn’t look as if to give to me alot of sentiment to me. Can someone please improve me? It’s so impregnable to convene the chick of my dreams.
Report comment
By howtomeetagirlyf | July 30, 2010
хонда от прямых дилеров в москве
Report comment
By onbshieyteam | July 31, 2010
камаз 4310
Report comment
By onbshieyteam | July 31, 2010